Clinical Report: Gender Bias Found in Regional Surgery Survey

Overview

A survey of a surgical association in the Anglophone Caribbean revealed that women surgeons were perceived as more frequently targeted by workplace gender discrimination compared to their male counterparts. Despite this perception, no significant differences in clinical judgment or surgical skill were reported between genders.

Background

Gender bias in the surgical field is a significant issue that can impact workforce participation and patient care. Understanding the perceptions of discrimination against women surgeons is crucial.

Data Highlights

Key Findings

• 64% of respondents observed discrimination against women surgeons.
• No statistically significant differences in clinical judgment or surgical skill were reported between genders.
• 47% of respondents perceived women surgeons as more thorough compared to 2% for men.
• 60% perceived women surgeons as better at task completion compared to 24% for men.
• Residents in training programs were more likely to perceive gender-based differences in thoroughness favoring women surgeons.
• The study's design did not directly measure implicit bias or establish causality.

Clinical Implications

The findings suggest that perceptions of gender discrimination in surgery may influence the work environment for women surgeons. Addressing these perceptions is essential for fostering a more inclusive surgical community.

Conclusion

The study highlights the ongoing issue of gender bias in surgery, emphasizing the need for further research and interventions to support women in the field.

Related Resources & Content

1. Cawich SO, et al., The Permanente Journal, 2025 -- Gender Bias Found in Regional Surgery Survey
2. Updates in Surgery — Examining Diversity Bias in Colorectal Surgery: A Worldwide Overview
3. Obstacles Faced by Women in Pursuing Surgical Careers: A Global Analysis of Medical Students' Views
4. BJS (British Journal of Surgery) — Assessing the Balance of Family Life, Pregnancy, and Early Parenthood Among Surgeons in Training in Switzerland: A National Survey Analysis
5. Surgical Endoscopy — Disparities in Awards Among Surgical Societies Based on Gender
6. Examining Diversity Bias in Colorectal Surgery: A Worldwide Overview
7. Obstacles Faced by Women in Pursuing Surgical Careers: A Global Analysis of Medical Students' Views
8. Assessing the Balance of Family Life, Pregnancy, and Early Parenthood Among Surgeons in Training in Switzerland: A National Survey Analysis
9. ACS Releases Workplace Standards Framework to Support Sustainable Surgical Careers
10. Long-Term Postoperative Outcomes by Surgeon Gender and Patient-Surgeon Gender Concordance in the US - PubMed
11. Mixed-Methods Evaluation of Surgeon Workplace Support and Obstetric Complications | Surgery | JAMA Surgery | JAMA Network