Comparison of the therapeutic effects of open psychiatric wards for patients with depression: a meta-analysis - Report - MDSpire

Comparison of the therapeutic effects of open psychiatric wards for patients with depression: a meta-analysis

  • By

  • Pingan Ni

  • Peiling Yao

  • Kaili Zhu

  • June 12, 2026

  • 0 min

Share

Clinical Report: Evaluating Treatment Outcomes in Open Versus Closed Psychiatric Wards

Overview

This meta-analytic review compares treatment outcomes for hospitalized patients with depression in open versus closed psychiatric wards. The findings indicate that open wards lead to better depression symptom scores and higher treatment adherence, although the effect on clinical response rates remains inconclusive.

Background

Depression is a prevalent mental disorder that significantly impacts individual functioning and public health. Inpatient care is crucial for patients with severe symptoms, and the management model of psychiatric wards can influence treatment experiences and outcomes. Understanding the differences between open and closed ward models is essential for optimizing psychiatric care.

Data Highlights

{'confidence_intervals': True}

Key Findings

{'future_studies': 'Address variability in open ward definitions.'}

Clinical Implications

{'safety_concerns': True}

Conclusion

{'national_contexts': True}

Related Resources & Content

  1. Conexiant, No Clear Benefit for Psychedelic Therapy, 2023 -- A systematic review of psychedelic-assisted therapy.
  2. Frontiers in Psychiatry, Comparative efficacy of non-pharmacological therapies in adolescents with subthreshold depression, 2023 -- A systematic review.
  3. npj Digital Medicine, The user experience of ambulatory assessment and mood monitoring in depression, 2023 -- A systematic review.
  4. NICE, Recommendations | Depression in adults: treatment and management, 2022 -- Guidance on depression management.
  5. Open-door policy versus treatment-as-usual in urban psychiatric inpatient wards, 2024 -- A pragmatic trial in Norway.
  6. Frontiers in Psychiatry — Efficacy of psychological interventions for adolescents with borderline personality disorder: a systematic review and meta-analysis
  7. Frontiers | Comparison of the Therapeutic Effects of Open Psychiatric Wards for Patients With Depression: A Meta-analysis
  8. Recommendations | Depression in adults: treatment and management | Guidance | NICE
  9. Open-door policy versus treatment-as-usual in urban psychiatric inpatient wards: a pragmatic, randomised controlled, non-inferiority trial in Norway - ScienceDirect

Original Source(s)

Related Content