Clinical Report: Imposter Syndrome Among Surgeons – Prevalence, Risks, and Mitigation
Overview
Imposter syndrome (IS) is prevalent among surgeons, with rates varying widely due to assessment methods and demographic factors. IS is linked to significant psychological distress, including anxiety, burnout, and reduced professional satisfaction, affecting surgeons across all career stages.
Background
Imposter syndrome is characterized by persistent self-doubt and a belief that one’s achievements are not due to genuine competence. It is multifactorial, influenced by demographic, familial, and environmental factors, and is commonly observed in high-pressure fields such as medicine. Surgeons face unique stressors including life-threatening decisions and a demanding work environment, which may exacerbate feelings of IS. Understanding IS in surgeons is critical due to its association with mental health challenges and professional consequences.
IS prevalence among surgeons ranges widely (9% to 82%), influenced by assessment methods and ethnic minority status.
Surgeons with IS are predisposed to mental health challenges including anxiety, depression, burnout, and suicidal ideation.
IS affects surgeons at all career stages, from trainees to consultants, across multiple surgical specialties.
Gender differences in IS prevalence exist but require further investigation to clarify impact.
Preventative and mitigating strategies for IS include fostering supportive environments and addressing perfectionism and self-doubt.
Most studies on IS in surgeons are cross-sectional with variable quality, highlighting the need for higher-quality longitudinal research.
Clinical Implications
Clinicians should recognize imposter syndrome as a systemic issue impacting surgeons’ mental health and professional performance. Early identification and targeted interventions, such as mentorship and psychological support, may reduce IS symptoms and improve well-being. Addressing IS can potentially decrease burnout and enhance job satisfaction among surgeons.
Conclusion
Imposter syndrome is a prevalent and impactful phenomenon among surgeons, contributing to significant psychological distress and professional challenges. Systematic efforts to understand and mitigate IS are essential to support surgeons’ mental health and optimize surgical care delivery.
References
Clance/Imposter Phenomenon Scale/1995 -- Measurement of Imposter Syndrome
Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument (MERSQI)/2010 -- Quality Assessment Tool
Forced deployments to immigration detention are pushing US public health clinicians to resign—and raising urgent questions about medical ethics, obedience, and harm.
