Collaborative EAES-SAGES Guidelines for Creating Surgical Quality Assessment Tools

Background

Surgical training has historically relied on time-based measures rather than competency-based assessments, leading to inconsistencies in evaluating technical skills. A standardized approach to surgical quality assurance is essential for improving the quality and comparability of these assessment tools across different surgical settings.

Data Highlights

No numerical or trial data was provided in the source material.

Key Findings

• The SQA-CAT Taskforce identified three guiding principles for the shared SQA framework: methodological rigour, feasibility across surgical settings, and adaptability for AI-based assessments.
• Both EAES and SAGES have developed their own SQA frameworks, which were compared during the taskforce meeting.
• The meeting aimed to align the two frameworks to propose a standardized best practice for CAT development.
• There is a need for a structured standardised SQA framework to guide the surgical community in competency assessment.
• Current CAT development practices are fragmented across surgical societies and institutions.

Clinical Implications

The establishment of a unified SQA framework may facilitate the development of more effective and comparable competency assessment tools in surgical training. This could lead to improved training outcomes and enhanced surgical quality assurance.

Conclusion

The collaborative efforts of EAES and SAGES in creating a standardized SQA framework focus on enhancing the assessment of surgical competencies.

Related Resources & Content

1. Surgical Endoscopy, 2023 -- Systematic Review of Video-Assisted Methods for Evaluating Technical Proficiency in Laparoscopic Surgery
2. Surgical Endoscopy, 2021 -- Recommendations from the ERAS Society for Enhancing Perioperative Care in Low- and Middle-Income Nations
3. Gastric Cancer, 2024 -- Creation of a dependable tool for surgical quality assurance in gastrectomy within cancer clinical trials
4. Frontiers in Oncology, 2026 -- Development and application of a quality evaluation scale for ERAS health education in gynecologic malignancies
5. Development of a robotic training curriculum for visceral and gastrointestinal surgical trainees: an international Delphi study - PMC
6. Development and Validity Evidence of a Trauma Laparotomy Operative Assessment Tool - PubMed
7. New England Journal of Medicine -- Surgical Skill and Complication Rates after Bariatric Surgery
8. Development of a robotic training curriculum for visceral and gastrointestinal surgical trainees: an international Delphi study - PMC
9. Development and Validity Evidence of a Trauma Laparotomy Operative Assessment Tool - PubMed
10. Surgical Skill and Complication Rates after Bariatric Surgery | New England Journal of Medicine