Retraction and Replacement Notice: Gross et al. on Selective Versus Routine Cholangiography Across a Health Care Enterprise
-
By
-
Toms Augustin
-
November 1, 2026
Clinical Report: Retraction and Replacement of Cholangiography Study
Overview
The retraction and replacement notice reports that post-publication review identified analytic concerns related to sparse-event modeling and statistical certainty in a study comparing routine with selective cholangiography. In the revised primary analysis, routine cholangiography was not significantly associated with major or minor bile duct injury; the authors also report no reduction in perioperative ERCP use and a clinically insignificant increase in operative time.
Background
The original investigation examined cholecystectomy outcomes among adults treated for benign biliary disease across 18 hospitals and 9 ambulatory surgery centers in the Cleveland Clinic Enterprise from January 2015 through June 2023. It included 28,212 procedures performed by 134 surgeons, with 26 major and 105 minor bile duct injuries. Because major injuries were rare and clustered among surgeons and hospitals, the authors and editors reviewed the original analytic approach after publication. The notice states that the article was retracted and replaced so the revised methods and findings would be presented consistently.
Data Highlights
| Measure | Reported result |
|---|---|
| Cholecystectomies | 28,212 (10,244 routine; 17,968 selective) |
| Major bile duct injuries | 26 (0.09%) |
| Minor bile duct injuries | 105 (0.34%) |
| Primary model for major injury | Firth penalized logistic regression with hospital fixed effects |
| Routine vs selective cholangiography: major injury | OR 0.48; 95% CI 0.18–1.31; not significant |
| Routine vs selective cholangiography: minor injury | OR 0.93; 95% CI 0.56–1.54; not significant |
| Clustering of major injuries | Five of 134 surgeons accounted for more than half; one hospital accounted for 10 of 26 |
Key Findings
- The original analysis reported lower adjusted odds of major and minor bile duct injury with routine cholangiography, but the authors state that additional analyses changed those primary findings.
- The revised primary analysis used Firth penalized logistic regression with hospital fixed effects to address sparse-event bias while accounting for hospital-level differences.
- In that model, routine cholangiography was not significantly associated with major bile duct injury (OR 0.48; 95% CI 0.18–1.31) or minor bile duct injury (OR 0.93; 95% CI 0.56–1.54).
- The revised conclusions state that routine cholangiography did not reduce major or minor bile duct injuries or perioperative ERCP use, and was associated with a clinically insignificant increase in operative time.
- Major bile duct injuries clustered: five surgeons accounted for more than half of the events, and one hospital accounted for nearly 40% (10 of 26).
- The authors retained hierarchical mixed-effects models with inverse-frequency weighting as a sensitivity analysis and added sensitivity analyses using alternative weighting strategies.
Clinical Implications
The notice identifies clustering of bile duct injuries as an opportunity for targeted local surveillance, case review, and safety interventions. The revised study findings do not establish a significant association between routine cholangiography and either major or minor bile duct injury in the primary model.
Conclusion
The replacement notice revises the study’s primary findings after review of sparse-event modeling and statistical certainty. The revised analysis found no significant association between routine cholangiography and major or minor bile duct injury, while documenting concentration of injuries among a small subset of surgeons and hospitals.
Related Resources & Content
- Gross et al., JAMA Surgery, 2025 — Notice of Retraction and Replacement. Gross et al. Selective vs Routine Cholangiography Across a Health Care Enterprise
- JAMA Surgery, year not specified — Text Revisions to the Invited Commentary on Selective vs Routine Cholangiography Across a Health Care Enterprise
- SAGES, 2025 — SAGES guidelines for the use of intraoperative imaging of the common bile duct
- Langenbecks Archives of Surgery — Editorial Expression of Concern: The efficacy of bedside percutaneous cholecystostomy in critically ill patients: comparison with cholecystostomy performed in angiography suite
- Surgical Endoscopy — Amendment: Challenges in Timing Interval Cholecystectomy After Percutaneous Cholecystostomy in Acute Calculous Cholecystitis Patients
- Surgical Endoscopy — Amendment: Laparoscopic Cholecystectomy Combined with Laparoscopy-Assisted Transgastric Rendezvous ERCP in Patients Undergoing Gastric Bypass Surgery
- Notice of Retraction and Replacement. Gross et al. Selective vs Routine Cholangiography Across a Health Care Enterprise
- SAGES guidelines for the use of intraoperative imaging of the common bile duct
- Association Between Intraoperative Cholangiogram Use and Cholecystectomy Outcomes
Based on findings from:
Notice of Retraction and Replacement. Gross et al. Selective vs Routine Cholangiography Across a Health Care
Toms Augustin. Jama Surgery, 2026.
https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamasurgery/fullarticle/2854294
This content is an AI-generated, fully rewritten summary based on a published scholarly article. It does not reproduce the original text and is not a substitute for the original publication. Readers are encouraged to consult the source for full context, data, and methodology.