Medical Mistrust Changes Over Time: Implications for Institutional Trustworthiness
-
By
-
Karl Patrick R. Mendoza
-
John Robert Bautista
-
November 20, 2026
Clinical Scorecard: Medical Mistrust Changes Over Time: Implications for Institutional Trustworthiness
At a Glance
| Category | Detail |
|---|---|
| Condition | Medical mistrust and public–institutional trust |
| Key Mechanisms | Trust changes through direct and vicarious experiences, institutional competence, honesty, fairness, care, accountability, and social and political information. |
| Target Population | US adults surveyed during the COVID-19 pandemic; the article also discusses health care practitioners and health institutions. |
| Care Setting | Public health and health care institutions, including patient care and community engagement during and beyond public health crises. |
Key Highlights
- A nationally representative cohort of 1,437 US adults surveyed from 2021 through 2022 showed four mistrust subgroups: strong, moderate, neutral, and none.
- Population proportions in the subgroups changed little, but only 18% to 35% of participants remained in the same category, depending on subgroup status.
- Transitions varied by race and ethnicity, education, and political orientation; several estimates were imprecise.
- The article argues that mistrust should not be treated as a fixed patient characteristic or as an identity imposed on individuals.
- Institutional trustworthiness is linked to being perceived as able, honest, and good; communication alone cannot compensate for inequitable care.
Guideline-Based Recommendations
Diagnosis
- Define the object of trust being assessed, such as government or private health institutions.
- Distinguish direct experiences from vicarious experiences, and interpret subgroup classifications as time-specific rather than fixed identities.
Management
- Disclose and correct errors openly, explain decisions clearly, follow through consistently, and provide accessible channels for questions and complaints.
- Engage communities in participatory decision-making, particularly communities affected by discrimination, exclusion, or underrepresentation.
- Address inequitable care and conditions such as systemic racism; symbolic reassurance alone does not address sources of harm.
- Train current and future health professionals to respond to health misinformation, alongside system-level efforts to enhance public trust.
Monitoring & Follow-up
- Measure trust more frequently around consequential encounters and public events to identify when transitions occur and whether they endure.
- Combine patient-reported judgments with institutional indicators, including disclosure practices, continuity of care, complaint responsiveness, and evidence of equitable treatment.
- Use qualitative inquiry to clarify how survey responses are understood across communities and why neutrality may be unstable.
- Social media listening and sentiment analysis may supplement survey data, but recommendations require caution because of noise and inauthentic messages.
Risks
- Stable population averages may conceal substantial individual movement between mistrust categories.
- Public mistrust contributed to COVID-19 misinformation and added demands on practitioners, with sustained misinformation response efforts contributing to burnout and adverse effects on workforce morale, staffing, and care delivery.
- Treating subgroup categories as enduring identities may misrepresent individuals’ changing judgments.
- Communication that does not address inequitable care may leave the foundations of mistrust unchanged.
Patient & Prescribing Data
The study described in the article surveyed a nationally representative cohort of 1,437 US adults during 2021–2022; no medication or prescribing population is specified.
No drug treatment is discussed. The article focuses on institutional practices, community engagement, workforce training, and research approaches related to trust and misinformation.
Clinical Best Practices
- Avoid labeling individuals or communities as intrinsically distrustful based on a single survey classification.
- Attend to the specific institution, experience, policy, or information context underlying a person’s trust judgment.
- Make institutional decision-making and error correction transparent and provide accessible routes for questions and complaints.
- Pair communication with action on inequitable care and community participation.
- Interpret social media listening cautiously and account for noise and inauthentic content.
Related Resources & Content
Based on findings from:
Medical Mistrust as a Dynamic Relationship—Implications for Institutional Trustworthiness
Karl Patrick R. Mendoza, John Robert Bautista. Jama Network Open, 2026.
https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2856811
This content is an AI-generated, fully rewritten summary based on a published scholarly article. It does not reproduce the original text and is not a substitute for the original publication. Readers are encouraged to consult the source for full context, data, and methodology.