To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of the Active Melioidosis Detect Plus rapid diagnostic test (AMD-RDT) for detecting Burkholderia pseudomallei in throat swabs, using culture as the reference standard.
Approach:
Study Design: A prospective diagnostic accuracy study using a 1:2 case-control design at microbiology laboratories in Cambodia and Laos.
Specimen Selection: Throat swabs were collected from patients with suspected melioidosis. Each culture-positive specimen served as a case, with the next two consecutive culture-negative specimens selected as controls.
Index Test: Stored aliquots underwent AMD-RDT testing, with results read after 15–20 minutes. Readers were not blinded to culture results.
Statistical Analysis: Sensitivity, specificity, and likelihood ratios were calculated using culture as the reference standard. Researchers tested 114 specimens: 38 cases and 76 controls.
Key Findings:
B. pseudomallei was cultured from 38 of 1451 throat swab specimens (2.6%).
AMD-RDT sensitivity was 18.4% (95% CI, 9.2%–33.4%), and specificity was 100% (95% CI, 95.2%–100%).
Positive AMD-RDT results occurred only in specimens positive on direct culture and were associated with greater growth abundance and culture positivity within 48 hours.
The throat swab was the sole culture-positive specimen in 20 of 38 cases (52.6%); 9 of 38 (23.7%) required enrichment culture for detection.
Interpretation:
Despite high specificity, the AMD-RDT has inadequate sensitivity on throat swabs and cannot reliably exclude melioidosis. Low antigen burden likely contributes to its poor sensitivity.
Limitations:
Delayed testing may have allowed degradation of the capsular polysaccharide targeted by the test, although accuracy was similar for testing within and after 4 days of specimen receipt.
Using a single swab for both culture and AMD-RDT testing may have limited yield.
Recruitment ended before the planned sample size of 234 specimens was reached.
Conclusion:
The findings do not support routine AMD-RDT use on throat swabs. Throat swabs and enrichment culture remain essential components of the diagnostic workup for melioidosis.
by Arjun Chandna, Sena Sao, Joy Silisouk, Amphone Sengduangphachanh, Thyl Miliya, David A.B. Dance, Sue J. Lee, Koukeo Phommasone, Keang Suy, Tamalee Roberts, Clare L. Ling