Comparative study on the efficacy of conservative treatment and surgical treatment for simple Mason II radial head fracture - Summary - MDSpire

Comparative study on the efficacy of conservative treatment and surgical treatment for simple Mason II radial head fracture

  • By

  • Wei Fan

  • Na Yang

  • Rui Qiao

  • Chen Wang

  • Chen Fei

  • Kun Zhang

  • Zhe Song

  • June 23, 2026

  • 0 min

Share

Objective:

To evaluate the treatment outcomes of conservative immobilization using braces compared to open reduction with internal fixation surgery for uncomplicated Mason II radial head fractures.

Approach:
    Key Findings:
    • Conservative treatment cohort had a mean fracture healing time of 10.41 weeks and a Broberg–Morrey score of 90.82, with average elbow flexion of 134.32° and extension of 7.65°.
    • Surgical treatment cohort had a mean fracture healing time of 10.92 weeks and a Broberg–Morrey score of 91.44, with average elbow flexion of 129.27° and extension of 5.26°.
    • No significant differences were observed between groups regarding healing time, elbow range of motion, or complication rates (P > 0.05).
    • One malunion occurred in the conservative group, while the surgical group had two postoperative infections and two internal-fixation failures.
    Interpretation:

    Both non-operative and operative interventions resulted in acceptable elbow functionality in uncomplicated Mason II fractures.

    Limitations:
    • Retrospective design may introduce bias.
    • Small sample size may limit generalizability.
    Conclusion:

    Preoperative computed tomography enhances fracture assessment.

Original Source(s)

Related Content