To assess whether postoperative suction drains are associated with blood loss, transfusion, length of stay, or complications after primary total hip or knee arthroplasty.
Approach:
Design and population: Retrospective, single-center cohort of 2,339 patients undergoing primary unilateral THA or TKA from January 2020 to May 2026.
Comparison: Propensity score matching produced 630 pairs (1,260 patients), matched on age, sex, and BMI with exact matching for procedure type. All patients received standardized care, including intra-articular tranexamic acid unless contraindicated.
Outcomes: Primary outcomes were postoperative day 1 hemoglobin decline and estimated blood loss. Secondary outcomes included day 2 measures, transfusions, length of stay, and complications within 3 months.
Key Findings:
On postoperative day 1, mean hemoglobin decline was 1.9 g/dL with drains versus 1.8 g/dL without; adjusted analysis associated drainage with an additional 0.16 g/dL decline.
Day 1 estimated blood loss was 634 mL with drains and 582 mL without. The adjusted 42 mL difference was not statistically significant.
Transfusion rates were 3.2% with drains and 2.1% without, with no statistically significant difference.
No statistically significant differences were detected in systemic or local complication rates.
Adjusted hospital stay was 12.5% longer with drainage, although the absolute difference was small; among TKA patients, mean stays were 4.2 versus 3.9 days.
Day 2 measures did not differ significantly in analyses of available data. Multiple imputation associated drainage with an additional 0.24 g/dL hemoglobin decline and 74 mL greater estimated blood loss.
Exploratory TKA subgroup comparisons showed greater day 1 hemoglobin decline and estimated blood loss with drains, but formal interaction testing found no significant difference by procedure type.
Interpretation:
The authors concluded that the findings do not support routine suction-drain use after primary total joint arthroplasty in the contemporary tranexamic acid era.
Limitations:
Retrospective, single-center design with potential selection bias.
Changes in drainage practice over time may have introduced temporal confounding and confounding by indication.
Postoperative day 2 hemoglobin measurements were incomplete; estimated blood loss calculations did not account for transfused blood or intravenous fluids.
Complications were uncommon, limiting the ability to detect group differences.
Longer-term functional and patient-reported outcomes were not evaluated.
Operative-time–adjusted findings favored the ipsilateral technique, while absolute fluoroscopy time and radiation exposure remained similar between approaches.
Postoperative rates of complex regional pain syndrome type 1 and pain and functional outcomes may improve among patients receiving prophylactic mecobalamin following foot and ankle surgery.